Chapter 43 : TOMMY'S CONFRONTATION
The Barren was the kind of bar that Tommy Merlyn would never have set foot in six months ago — wood paneling that hadn't been updated since the Carter administration, a bartender whose conversational range extended from what'll it be to tab's due, and a clientele that drank with the purposeful efficiency of people who came for the alcohol and not the ambiance. Post-Undertaking Tommy drank differently than pre-Undertaking Tommy. The tabloids had noticed.
He was at a corner table when I arrived, two glasses already present — whiskey, neat, one for each of us. The choice was deliberate. Tommy Merlyn was a man whose social fluency had been shaped by a lifetime of charity galas and country club brunches, and the decision to drink cheap whiskey in a dive bar said something about the terrain this conversation would occupy.
I sat down. The chair was wooden, unpadded, the kind that creaked whether you wanted it to or not. Tommy's hands were wrapped around his glass, not drinking, just holding — the same grip Helena used with coffee cups when the thing she needed was the warmth and not the contents.
"Thanks for coming."
"You asked."
"I asked three weeks ago. You didn't respond for nineteen days."
"I was unavailable."
Tommy's eyes held mine. The fear from the parking lot and the relief station had metabolized into something harder during those nineteen days — not terror anymore, but the grim determination of a man who'd decided to confront something impossible and was doing it the way Merlyns did everything: head-on, with expensive whiskey and a steady voice.
"I need to know what you are, Charles."
The sentence arrived without preamble, without small talk, without the social lubrication that Tommy Merlyn had spent his entire life applying to difficult conversations. The Undertaking had stripped the varnish off him. What remained was a man who'd watched his father get arrested, his best friend's mother exposed as complicit in mass murder, and a stranger die under a steel beam and walk away.
"I'm a person."
"People don't come back from what happened to you in that stairwell."
"Some do."
"Don't." Tommy's voice dropped. Not anger — control. The specific, measured control of someone who'd been practicing this conversation in his head for weeks and wouldn't tolerate deflection. "I heard your spine break. I know what that sounds like because I spent two nights in a hospital watching my father's victims die with the same injuries, and the doctors explained every one. Thoracic compression. Crush syndrome. The beam hit you across the upper back and you went flat and your body stopped moving in the way bodies stop moving when the central nervous system loses connection with everything below the impact point."
His medical precision was unexpected. Tommy had been volunteering at Starling General in the aftermath — the tabloids had covered that too, the billionaire heir washing sheets and carrying trays while the cameras rolled. But the medical knowledge wasn't for cameras. It was for understanding what he'd witnessed, the intellectual framework of a man who needed to categorize the impossible before he could accept it.
"And then you were standing in a parking lot with different dust on your jacket."
"I have an ability." The words came from a place I'd rehearsed but the delivery still cost something — each syllable a brick removed from the wall between Charles Weston's real life and the life everyone else could see. "It keeps me alive. When I should die — when my body fails — I come back. I can't explain the mechanism because I don't fully understand it myself. I didn't choose it. I didn't ask for it. It's something that happens to me, and I use it to help people."
Tommy stared. The glass in his hands rotated — a quarter-turn, then back, the nervous fidgeting of a man processing information through his fingers because his mind was already full.
"How many times?"
"More than I'd like."
"How many times, Charles."
"Nine." Including the Crucible Trial death I could feel approaching but hadn't experienced yet. Eight, technically. The ninth was coming. "Each one hurts. Each one I remember. It's not a magic trick. It's..." I searched for the word that would carry the weight without revealing the machinery. "It costs something every time."
The bar's ambient noise filled the silence — a jukebox playing something from the nineties, the clink of a glass being set down two tables away, the bartender running water. Tommy's eyes hadn't left mine. PER 13 tracked the evaluation: the jaw relaxation that indicated acceptance rather than resistance, the shoulder drop that said the tension was releasing into something more sustainable than adrenaline.
"Does Oliver know?"
"No."
"Does anyone know?"
"One other person. She's seen me come back. She doesn't know the details either."
Helena. The name I didn't say, because Tommy knowing about Helena created a connection chain that could compromise both of them. Tommy didn't push for the name. He was smart enough to recognize an information boundary and disciplined enough not to cross it.
The whiskey sat untouched. Tommy picked it up, finally, and drank — not a sip but a committed swallow, the kind that said the decision had been made and the lubrication was retrospective.
"Oliver keeps secrets. My father kept secrets. Everyone in my life keeps secrets that turn out to be life-or-death." He set the glass down. "If your secret ever — ever — puts my family at risk, I'm done. I tell Oliver everything. I tell the police. I tell whoever needs to know to keep the people I care about safe."
"Understood."
"And you don't die for me again." His voice cracked on die. The first break in the composure, the moment where Tommy Merlyn's practiced control couldn't quite contain the memory of a man's back breaking under a steel beam. "I didn't ask for that. I didn't want it. Whatever you are — whatever this ability costs you — I'm not worth it."
"You're worth it."
The words came out before the project manager could filter them, arriving from a place deeper than strategy, from the specific wellspring of a man who'd watched Tommy Merlyn die on a television screen in another life and had crossed realities and spent five months and died eight times to make sure it didn't happen in this one.
Tommy's expression shifted. The evaluation was over. What replaced it wasn't trust — trust required understanding, and understanding required information Tommy didn't have and Charles couldn't provide. But it was something adjacent to trust. Acceptance, maybe. The decision to coexist with a mystery because the alternative was a world where the mystery hadn't saved his life.
He finished the whiskey. Set money on the table — enough for both drinks and a tip that said old habits survived even when the man paying had been fundamentally reshaped.
"I'm going to have questions."
"I know."
"I'm going to ask them when I'm ready."
"I'll be here."
He left. The bar door swung shut behind him. The jukebox played. The bartender wiped.
I picked up my whiskey — untouched for the duration of the conversation because drinking while delivering partial truths to a traumatized man seemed like the kind of multitasking that crossed a line. I drank it in one swallow, the way Tommy had, and the warmth hit my stomach like a small mercy.
The phone sat on the table. No notifications. No missions. No Helena texts. Just the silence of a Tuesday evening in a dive bar where a man with nine lives had just promised a man with one that the lives were being spent well.
I paid. Walked out into the April night, lighter by one secret and heavier by one promise I intended to keep even if keeping it cost deaths I'd stopped counting.
Want more? The story continues on Patreon!
If you can't wait for the weekly release, you can grab +10, +15, or +20 chapters ahead of time on my Patreon page. Your support helps me keep this System running!
Read ahead here: [ patreon.com/system_enjoyer ]