The church overflowed for Sheila Bennett's funeral.
She'd touched more lives than I'd realized—students she'd mentored, colleagues she'd befriended, neighbors who remembered her from decades of community involvement. The pews were packed, standing room only, a testament to a woman who'd spent her life quietly helping others while secretly training to fight supernatural threats.
I sat in the back, far from the family section where Bonnie sat rigid and unmoving. Caroline held my hand without knowing why I needed it. She'd noticed something was wrong—of course she had—but she hadn't pressed for answers yet. That would come later.
The minister spoke about Sheila's dedication to education, her love for her granddaughter, her strength of character. He didn't mention witchcraft or vampires or the fact that she'd died channeling enough magical energy to seal a tomb full of monsters. He couldn't. The truth would have been incomprehensible to everyone in this church except the handful of us who'd been there.
Elena sat with Bonnie, Stefan beside her with an expression of careful grief. He'd known Grams—they'd talked several times about vampire lore and Bennett history. He'd respected her. And now she was gone because of a plan we'd all agreed to, a deal with his brother that had gone exactly as badly as we'd feared.
I watched Bonnie's face throughout the service. She didn't cry. Didn't move. Just sat there, staring at the coffin, her expression locked in something beyond grief. Something closer to stone.
She's going to blame me.
The thought crystallized as the service ended and people began filing past the family to offer condolences. I saw it in the way Bonnie's eyes tracked me across the church. In the slight tightening of her jaw when our gazes met.
I deserved it. The plan had been mine. The deal with Damon, the controlled opening, the timeline that had put everyone at that tomb on that night—all of it traced back to decisions I'd made.
The wake was held at the Bennett house, familiar rooms now crowded with mourners and casseroles and the quiet murmur of people who didn't know what to say. I helped where I could—refilling drinks, carrying plates, staying busy to avoid thinking.
Caroline cornered me in the kitchen. "You look like you're about to fall apart."
"I'm fine."
"You're not fine. You haven't been fine since before that night—whatever happened that night that you won't tell me about." She touched my face, forcing me to meet her eyes. "I'm not pushing. Not today. But eventually, Matt, you're going to have to let me in."
"I know." The words came out rough, scraped from somewhere deep. "Just... not yet."
She kissed my forehead and let me go. I didn't deserve her patience.
The confrontation came an hour later, when the crowd had thinned and only close friends remained.
Bonnie found me in the backyard, standing alone by her grandmother's herb garden. The plants were dormant for winter, but I could see the careful arrangement—magical herbs mixed with culinary ones, practical witchcraft disguised as gardening.
"She talked about you," Bonnie said, her voice flat. "Before... at the end. She said you had potential. That your blood abilities could change things."
"Bonnie—"
"She died because of your plan." The words came out like bullets, each one aimed to wound. "Your deal with Damon. Your brilliant strategy to control the tomb opening. You brought vampires into her life. You dragged her into your war."
"I tried to protect—"
"She's DEAD, Matt." Bonnie's voice cracked, grief finally breaking through the stone. "Your protection means nothing. Your plans mean nothing. She's in the ground because you thought you could control things that can't be controlled."
I had no defense. She was right. I'd thought I could manage the situation, balance the competing interests, extract the outcome I wanted through careful negotiation and preparation. And Grams had paid the price for my arrogance.
"I'm sorry," I said. "I'm so sorry."
"Sorry doesn't bring her back." Bonnie turned away, shoulders shaking. "Stay away from me, Matt. Stay away from my family. Whatever alliance we had—it's over."
She walked back into the house without looking back. Elena appeared at the door a moment later, her expression torn between loyalty to her friend and something more complicated. She didn't speak—just watched me for a long moment, then followed Bonnie inside.
I stood alone in the garden, surrounded by dormant herbs and the fading warmth of the afternoon sun. Another bridge burned. Another relationship destroyed by the realities of supernatural warfare.
You tried to save everyone. You saved no one who mattered.
The thought was cruel but accurate. I'd kept Caroline safe, kept Elena alive, protected the town from a vampire massacre. But Grams was dead and Bonnie was broken and Damon was somewhere in the wind with a shattered heart and a monster's rage.
Some victories felt exactly like defeat.
Caroline found me an hour after everyone else had left. She didn't say anything—just sat beside me on Grams' garden bench and held my hand while the sun set.
I visited Grams' grave after Caroline drove me home. Fresh earth, fresh flowers, fresh pain. I placed a small vial of my blood on the headstone—healing power she'd helped me develop, magic she'd believed I could master.
"I'm sorry," I whispered to the stone. "I'm sorry I wasn't enough."
The wind didn't answer. It never did.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0